International Review of Business, Trade, and Economics
Input Tax Credit Reversal under Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act: Reconciling Revenue Protection with Taxpayer Rights and Constitutional Fairness
Abstract
Zeba
Input Tax Credit (ITC) constitutes one of the central features of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime in India. It is intended to prevent the cascading effect of taxation by permitting a registered person to set off eligible input tax against the tax liability arising on outward supplies. The availability of credit, however, is subject to the statutory conditions contained in section 16 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act 2017 (CGST Act). Among these conditions, section 16(2)(c), which requires that the tax charged in respect of a supply be actually paid to the Government, has generated considerable litigation where a supplier fails to discharge the corresponding tax liability.
The resulting controversy raises a fundamental question: should a bona fide purchaser lose input tax credit because of a default committed by the supplier over whom the purchaser may have limited or no effective control? The issue becomes particularly significant where the recipient possesses a valid tax invoice, has actually received the goods or services, has paid the supplier the agreed consideration including GST, and has otherwise complied with the requirements of the GST law.
The judicial response has not always been uniform. Courts have emphasised different aspects of the statutory scheme, including the recipient’s compliance, the department’s obligation to investigate the supplier, revenue protection, and the prevention of fraudulent transactions. Decisions such as Suncraft Energy Pvt Ltd v Assistant Commissioner, State Tax demonstrate judicial concern with automatic reversal of ITC from a purchaser without appropriate proceedings against the supplier.
This article critically examines section 16(2)(c) from statutory, constitutional and judicial perspectives. It evaluates the competing claims of revenue protection and taxpayer fairness and considers whether blanket denial of ITC is proportionate where the purchaser has acted in good faith. It argues that GST enforcement should distinguish between genuine purchasers and participants in fraudulent arrangements. A risk-based verification mechanism, a bona fide purchaser protection, stronger action against defaulting suppliers and appropriate legislative clarification could provide a more balanced approach to the problem.

