International Review of Business, Trade, and Economics
From Required Return on Equity to WACC, FCFE, FCFF, and EVA: A Closed-Loop Audit of Exact Fixed-WACC Closure, Broken-Date Floating-WACC Diagnostics, and Schedule-Consistent Replication
Abstract
Hany Hassanien Badr
This paper reconstructs, cell by cell, the path from capital structure to the required return on equity (Ke), the workbook’s weighted average cost of capital (WACC), free cash flow to equity (FCFE), free cash flow to the firm (FCFF), economic value added (EVA), financing movements, discount factors, and continuing value within one linked closed-loop model. The study separates three evidentiary layers that are often conflated in valuation work: cash-flow identity, valuation closure, and temporal consistency. It audits two distinct workbook regimes and does not treat them as a one-factor experiment. Scenario C combines a 5% higher-sales operating path with full-year timing and a fixed WACC of 17.6753653%. Scenario A retains the baseline operating path, uses a floating WACC generated from the leverage-to-beta-to-Ke chain, and is valued from a deliberately broken first forecast interval of 108/365 of a year. In Scenario C, five separately formulated FCFE derivation/check routes reproduce the same annual FCFE series. Adding the workbook debt-movement and financing-charge rows to FCFE reconstructs FCFF exactly in every year from 2005 through 2009. The same claim- conservation logic extends into continuing value: FCFF continuing value of 120,290.0452 less FCFE continuing value of 108,791.1362 leaves a total financing gap of 11,498.9090, which is exactly decomposed into 2,121.0000 of debt movement and a 9,377.9090 model-defined terminal financing component (labelled “Tax Shield for Debt” in the workbook). The terminal bridge therefore closes with zero residual. Under this internally consistent fixed-rate regime, the principal FCFF/DCF and EVA routes produce the identical equity value of 335.0839028 per share. Scenario A is used as the more demanding temporal diagnostic. Its raw workbook outputs are 320.9936089 per share from the DCF sheet, 320.9962697 from the integrated FCFF route, and 321.7155488 from the EVA/economic-value route. These are two different residuals and are therefore decomposed separately. The DCF-to-integrated-FCFF difference is fully attributable to a one-unit 2008 FCFF discrepancy: the integrated route uses 8,300 while the DCF route uses 8,299 because their operating-capital/net-investment paths differ by one unit. Discounted at 0.5853884991, that unit explains 0.5853885 model units, or 0.0026609 per share, exactly. The larger DCF-to-EVA residual is temporal rather than an accounting- identity failure: the EVA capital-charge sequence does not satisfy the recursion implied by the DCF discount factors. For any discount-factor sequence D_t with D_0 = 1, exact residual-income/DCF closure requires k_t* = D_{t-1}/D_t - 1, equivalently D_{t-1} = (1 + k_t*)D_t. Replication R1 preserves Scenario A’s DCF discount-factor schedule and operating cash-flow data, replaces only the capital-charge sequence with the schedule-implied k_t* rates, and restores exact DCF/EVA operating-value equality at 71,168.593948; after the same non-operating adjustments, the result remains 320.9936089 per share. Replication R2 asks the converse question: it preserves the displayed floating-WACC path, converts the first 15.7822% annual rate to its 108-day effective rate of 4.4314%, and then rebuilds later discount factors sequentially. That second internally consistent architecture also closes exactly, at an operating value of 72,165.379330, although at a different valuation level. The result is therefore structural: exact closure depends on matching cash-flow boundaries, discount factors, capital charges, and terminal treatment, whereas the numerical value level depends on the chosen rate-time convention. The paper does not interpret the approximately 321 versus 335 per-share values as the isolated effect of floating versus fixed WACC because Scenarios A and C also differ in operating assumptions. Its contribution is methodological and diagnostic, not a claim to have discovered CAPM, WACC, the FCFE-FCFF identity, or DCF-EVA equivalence: the contribution is to make the full chain auditable, identify the exact source of each residual, and demonstrate how temporal consistency restores closure.

